HB 438: Prohibiting Self-Incrimination with Biometric Phone Access

This bill was held in committee.

Libertas Institute supports this bill

Staff review of this legislation finds that it is aligned with our principles and merits support.

Utah’s Constitution says that “The accused shall not be compelled to give evidence against himself”—a slightly stronger version of what’s in the U.S. Constitution’s 5th amendment.

Several stories have emerged of police officers gaining access to a person’s phone using biometric access—the person’s finger print or facial scan. Because people don’t typically think about self-incrimination when using their face the same way they might if they were asked to divulge their password, these stories have illustrated a problem in the current law.

Representative Adam Robertson is sponsoring House Bill 438 to state that:

A law enforcement officer may not use and a court may not order an individual to provide the individual’s biometric information for a law enforcement officer to access the individual’s personal electronic device that is protected by biometric security.

This is a concern seen by many attorneys. For example, a staff attorney with the Legal Aid Society noted that, “Traditionally, using a person’s face as evidence or to obtain evidence would be considered lawful. But never before have we had so many people’s own faces be the key to unlock so much of their private information.”

People should not be required or requested to incriminate themselves, and given the ease of doing so by using biometric information, this legislation is necessary.

About the author

Libertas Institute Staff

Share Post:

Fighting for a Future Where Individuals Are Fully Liberated to Pursue Their Dreams, Free from Coercion and Control.

You Might Also Like

This bill reduces barriers to entry in the cosmetology and beauty industry while maintaining consumer choice.
This bill ensures that Utah’s medicinal psilocybin and MDMA pilot program can move forward by allowing qualified healthcare providers to participate after the initial healthcare systems declined to do so.
This bill provides for improved guardrails and oversight of automatic license plate readers used and accessed by law enforcement and transportation management.

Help us Nail and Scale Policies to Reduce Government Control

Your tax-deductible contributions to Libertas Institute increase freedom across the country.

Libertas Institute
Privacy Overview

This website uses cookies so that we can provide you with the best user experience possible. Cookie information is stored in your browser and performs functions such as recognising you when you return to our website and helping our team to understand which sections of the website you find most interesting and useful.