Your Backyard Is Not a Crime Scene: Police Drones Need Oversight

 

IN THE NEWS

In a recent Salt Lake Tribune letter to the editor, a Salt Lake City resident described an SLCPD drone hovering over his backyard for approximately 20 seconds while he was grilling, despite no apparent emergency. His experience raises an important question: When does a public-safety tool become a surveillance tool?

HERE’S MY TAKE

SLCPD’s own website promises:

“At no point will we use an unmanned aircraft for random surveillance of any private property.”

Whether this particular flight violated that promise remains unclear, but that’s precisely the problem: Utahns deserve transparency about how surveillance technologies are deployed and used.

From police drones to automated license plate readers (ALPRs), technologies capable of monitoring our movements and activities are becoming increasingly sophisticated. While these tools may serve legitimate public-safety purposes, internal policies and promises alone are insufficient safeguards.

Government agencies should be required to obtain affirmative approval through a transparent public process before deploying new surveillance technologies, with clear limitations on their use, data retention, and oversight.

CLOSING

Utahns shouldn’t have to discover the extent of government surveillance by looking up and finding a drone overhead. Privacy protections and public accountability should come before deployment, not after.

Author Profile Image
About the author

Emily Grimmius

Emily is a passionate advocate who has a demonstrated history of changing laws in state legislatures, negotiating cutting-edge privacy bills in the Senate, and served crime victims as a Manhattan prosecutor. With a passion for the Fourth Amendment, privacy protections, and how emerging technologies co-exist with current laws, Emily looks forward to working with Libertas to transform privacy protections for all.

Share Post:

Fighting for a Future Where Individuals Are Fully Liberated to Pursue Their Dreams, Free from Coercion and Control.

You Might Also Like

Utah should encourage its residents to save, invest, and build wealth, rather than imposing additional obstacles along the way.
Shoving and injuring a woman is a crime. So is keeping her in a room against her will. But a shove and a blocked doorway should not be punished like a murder.
Investing in the stock market, for example, also involves risk-taking, yet it is generally regulated as investing rather than gambling. This naturally raises the question: Where should regulators draw the line between investing and gambling?

Help us Nail and Scale Policies to Reduce Government Control

Your tax-deductible contributions to Libertas Institute increase freedom across the country.