Homeschooling Isn’t the Problem

Gavin Peterson’s family pulled him out of school to homeschool after allegations of abuse were brought against the father. The end result was a tragic death, leading some to call for more regulation of homeschool families. 

(GoFundMe) Gavin Peterson, 12, died in July after authorities suspect his father, stepmother and older brother abused him for “several years.”

Homeschooling Isn’t the Problem

This isn’t the first time individuals call for stronger regulation on homeschooling following a tragedy. It is a knee-jerk reaction, trying to prevent something bad from happening again. 

But homeschooling isn’t the problem. Abusive parents are. 

In fact, Brian Ray researched rates of abuse among homeschool families versus traditionally schooled families. He found that there was no difference in the rate of abuse between the two populations. Furthermore, abuse rates in homeschooling were about the same in states with strict or relaxed rules.

More rules won’t prevent tragedy.

Utah Governor Spencer Cox seems to agree with this idea, stating, “We’re never going to have [a] government big enough to be living in people’s houses to be able to prevent all of this.” And he’s right. The real issue isn’t homeschooling—it’s abusive individuals.

Protect Homeschool Freedom

The vast majority of homeschool families do it to meet the unique needs of their child. Putting restrictions on them disrupts their freedom. Homeschooling parents are able to individualize education in a way that a traditional school simply cannot. Creating limits will damage that ability, harming homeschooling families.

Author Profile Image
About the author

Jon England

Jon is the Education Policy Analyst at Libertas Institute. He is a fourteen-year veteran of public schools. He taught both fifth and sixth grades, receiving Weber District’s E+ Team Award. He proudly homeschools his children with his wife. Jon received his bachelor’s degree in elementary education from the University of Utah and a master’s degree in educational leadership from Western Governors University. He spent time in the Marine Corps and separated as a sergeant in 2006. During his time in public schools, Jon increasingly understood the importance of parental empowerment in education. This increased understanding led him to join Libertas to provide educational freedom for families. Jon enjoys spending time with his wife and five children traveling, skiing, and playing games.

Share Post:

Fighting for a Future Where Individuals Are Fully Liberated to Pursue Their Dreams, Free from Coercion and Control.

You Might Also Like

Nearly two-thirds of Utahns support the Utah Fits All Scholarship — because when families are free to choose what works, kids thrive.
If AI can finish a school assignment in seconds, maybe the problem isn’t the student—it’s the assignment.
As America races to lead the AI revolution, a battle is unfolding between innovation and overregulation.

Help us Nail and Scale Policies to Reduce Government Control

Your tax-deductible contributions to Libertas Institute increase freedom across the country.