Should Government Dictate Home Sizes?

Housing discussions often center around the size of new homes being built in neighborhoods. Beyond deciding the dimensions and style of their own homes, some advocate for regulations that impose maximums, minimums, and aesthetic restrictions on their entire community. This inevitably raises broader questions about individual rights and who should make such decisions, property owners or the government.

Where Utah Ranks

According to an analysis from 2022, Utah boasts the largest average home size in the country, measuring 2,800 square feet. For context, the median U.S. home size was 1,595 square feet in 1980, 2,057 square feet in 2000, and 2,261 square feet in 2020. The state’s larger homes are often attributed to cultural preference for larger families, available land, and its historically affordable housing market. 

Large homes like this are joking referred to as “McMansions”

The Loss of Personal Preference

In many cases, individuals haven’t had the freedom to determine their home or lot size. Since zoning was introduced in the 1920s, the government has steadily increased its involvement in regulating the details of home construction. Lot sizes are almost universally regulated by the government through local zoning laws. Home sizes are required to meet a minimum size as well, although a state law passed in 2021 limited such restrictions in Utah. 

A Question of Fairness

The trend toward regulating lot sizes, home sizes, and styles can have significant implications for housing affordability. When local governments impose minimum square footage or mandate specific aesthetic standards, the cost of building a home increases. This can drive up home prices and make it difficult for first-time buyers or middle-income families to enter the market. By restricting what can be built, these regulations limit options for those who might prefer smaller, more affordable homes.

Small lot home.

Restoring Individual Choice

Ultimately, on the topic of home sizes, what is needed is the return of individual choice. Families and individuals have diverse needs that a standardized approach simply cannot address. A new family on a tight budget may need to save money and purchase a small home on a small lot, while a retiree might have the means for a home with a spacious office or guest rooms for visiting family. Whatever the situation or personal desire, property owners should have the flexibility to build homes that reflect their specific lifestyle requirements, rather than being forced to conform to arbitrary zoning restrictions.

About the author

Lee Sands

Lee is the Local Government Policy Analyst at Libertas Institute. He has had a lifelong passion for research, writing, entrepreneurship, local government, and building relationships with people from all walks of life. Before joining Libertas, Lee worked as a technical writer, covered tech and local events as a journalist, developed websites, launched a Kickstarter campaign, and helped businesses create budgets and integrate accounting and other systems. A native of rural northeast Florida, Lee moved to Provo, Utah in 2004. Since graduating from BYU and attending the Vermont College of Fine Arts, Lee has started a family, become increasingly active in local politics as a volunteer, and now joins Libertas to be a resource for elected officials and the general public. Lee enjoys camping, fishing, Jeeping, history, and all things creative and analytical.

Share Post:

Fighting for a Future Where Individuals Are Fully Liberated to Pursue Their Dreams, Free from Coercion and Control.

You Might Also Like

The Utah Fits All Scholarship program is still alive. This legal fight is far from over. But for now, Utah families can move forward.
What if we’d regulated the internet before Google, Amazon, or email even existed—are we about to make the same mistake with AI?
This ruling may feel like a full stop, but it’s only a pause. The fight to give Utah parents and kids education choice is far from over.

Help us Nail and Scale Policies to Reduce Government Control

Your tax-deductible contributions to Libertas Institute increase freedom across the country.

Libertas Institute
Privacy Overview

This website uses cookies so that we can provide you with the best user experience possible. Cookie information is stored in your browser and performs functions such as recognising you when you return to our website and helping our team to understand which sections of the website you find most interesting and useful.